Teaching 3rd and 4th Graders How to Compare Fractions

It is important to remember that while fractions may come easily to adults, this is a completely new concept for 8-10 year olds. The significance of the numerator and denominator are still foreign concepts.

Children are used to knowing 10 wholes are more than 5 wholes. Now, for the first time, they are being asked to understand why 1/5 is more than 1/10. When first looking at the fractions, many students compare the 5 and 10 in the denominator, and mistakenly assume 1/10 is more than 1/5.

For this reason, the use of diagrams, manipulatives and number lines are essential.

Lessons on comparing fractions with the same denominator or the same numerator are a powerful introduction to the significance of the numbers in fractions.

Showing students how 3/4 and 4/12 are equivalent will be easier later on if they have already grappled with the question – which is greater 3/12 or 7/12? Although this answer may seem obvious to adults, you might be surprised by the answers you get when you ask your students or child.

Having two numbers representing part of a whole is initially as foreign to young children as many long algebraic or calculus equations are adults.

Illustrative Mathematics’ IM Grade 3 Math™ Unit 5 gives specific lessons on comparing the fractions with: 1) the same numerator 2) the same denominator. These lessons teach students how to use a variety of diagrams to compare and order fractions. Students become familiar with fractions on a number line and drawing pie or rectangular diagrams.

Math Sparkz worksheets are directly aligned with Illustrative Mathematics’ IM Grade 3 Math™ Unit 5 and give students lots of space to work out their thinking.

Students are given a variety of practice problems. Students are prompted to explain their mathematical thinking in words as well – preparing them for the written math performance questions on state tests at the end of the year.

Leave a comment

I’m Lindsay Thompson

My goal is to assist you in giving children lots of opportunities to become successful in math! 

Every teacher has a classroom full of different learners. Math Sparkz provides differentiated approaches so that all children can build a solid foundation in math standards.

My materials are based on the IM K-12 Math™ authored by Illustrative Mathematics®. Teachers using this program have found my worksheets to be great extra practice, homework or small group materials.

I’m glad you’re here! Get a free 3rd or 4th grade packet AND a free decimals packet when you subscribe to my email list via these links.

Let’s connect